Apriori Advisors LLP

Employee Benefits | Non-Life Insurance

Tag: Gratuity

  •  Mr. Pillai v HDFC Bank

    Mr. P.V. Unnikrishna Pillai is an ex-employee of HDFC Bank.

    According to market practice, at the end of his service, he was paid 5.95 lacs as gratuity for 16 years of service based on his last drawn basic + DA. Mr. Pillai observed a component named personal pay in his salary breakup and wanted to verify whether component could be a part of the salary eligible for gratuity.

    According to POGA 1972, wages are defined as

    “Wages” means all emoluments which are earned by an employee while on duty or on leave in accordance with the terms and conditions of his employment and which are paid or are payable to him in cash and includes dearness allowance but does not include any bonus, commission, house rent allowance, overtime wages and any other allowance.”

    The above is interpreted as follows to arrive the salary for Gratuity,

    • include basic pay & DA
    • exclude allowances and other components (as defined in the Act).

    Mr. Pillai found that personal pay does not form a part of the “exclusions” list. Whatever is not (explicitly) excluded can be a part of the inclusions (i.e. basic + DA).

    Therefore, if personal pay were to be included in the definition of Wages, his gratuity eligibility would be 13.17 lacs (v/s 5.95 lacs actually paid).

    Mr. Pillai went to the Controlling Authority claiming that his gratuity was underestimated and personal pay should be a part of his gratuity workings. Turns out, the ruling turned out to be in his favor. Mr.Aneish Ravindra, Assistant Labour Commissioner, Ernakulam, mentioned in his order.

    “In the instant case, it is pertinent to note that with respect to the components of the salary of the applicant, the term used by the employer is ‘personal pay’ instead of ‘personal allowance’ and all other components of the salary are specifically termed as ‘allowances’.”

    The order specifically mentions that if it was personal allowance, it would be excluded. Since, it’s not the case, Mr. Pillai’s claim stands.

    HDFC appealed.

    The Deputy Chief Labour Commissioner (Central) ruled in HDFC’s favor saying that gratuity is to be paid only on basic pay, personal pay is not be included in the definition of wages. However, at the time of final hearing, Mr. Pillai’s counsel was not present due to serious illness and Mr. Pillai was not able to properly defend his case.

    The Appellate Authority ruled in HDFC’s favor.

    Mr. Pillai persisted and went to High Court to appeal the ruling and argued that the order was ex-parte (decision was made without hearing the other party’s side). The High Court ruled in Mr. Pillai’s favor and ordered The Appellate Authority to conduct the appeal hearing again.

    The ruling was passed in October 2024. As of this writing (March 2025), there are no further updates on the case.

    In the interim, HDFC faces some serious financial implications due to the preliminary order.

    • Should it include personal pay to determine gratuity for employees resigning henceforth?
    • Should it include the component in determining the year-end actuarial liability? The following is a snapshot from HDFC’s Mar’22 balance sheet.
    • As on Mar’22, the Gratuity liability was 375 cr. If personal pay were included in working out Gratuity, assuming Mr. Pillai’s increase of 120% across the board, this could go up to 840 Cr.
    • If the company doesn’t choose to fund the liability, the net balance sheet provision can up from 86 Cr. to 565 Cr. An approx. ~6x increase in a single financial year.

    The interim order is bound impact everyone else and not just HDFC. It calls for employers to review their pay components. With Code on Social Security implementation around the corner, the outcome of this case has the potential to set a jurisdictional precedent for the industry at large.


  • Code on Social Security, 2020 – Impact on Gratuity

    Introduction

    The social security codes were introduced in 2019-20 with an intent to consolidate and simplify prevailing labour law framework to promote ease of doing business and accelerate the nation toward the vision of Viksit Bharat 2047.

    On 21st November 2025, the Central government partially notified the Wages and Social Security codes and fully notified the Industrial Relations and Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions codes.

    The official gazette notification issued on 21st November 2025 partially notified the Code on Social Security, 2020 (SS Code). The notification includes effective immediate implementation of sections 1 through 14 and sections 17 through 141 of the SS code.

    The above sections include the provisions pertaining to Gratuity. The effective implementation mandates organizations to follow the SS code going forth.

    Continuation of legislation

    The gazette notifies;
    – items 1 and 2 and items 4 to 9 of sub-section (1) of section 164; and
    – clause (a) and clause (c) of sub-section (2) and sub-section (3) of section 164.

    Under these clauses, the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (hereinafter referred to as POGA 1972) is repealed by the SS Code and the new rules become applicable.

    Section 164(2)(a) ensures smooth transition from POGA 1972 to the SS Code. It also ensures continuation of laws such as Karnataka Compulsory Gratuity Insurance Rules 2024 wherein amendments were made under POGA 1972 Section 4A. These amendments continue to be applicable unless they contradict with the SS Code.

    Employee Definitions

    The SS Code is more specific in its definition of an employee.

    Fixed Term Employees

    Section 2(26)explicitly states a person “employed on wages by an establishment, either directly or through a contractor” as an employee. 

    In our view, this is an important shift from the existing legislation. The employee definition is now expanded to include fixed term contractual employees.  

    Section 2(34)defines fixed term employment as “the engagement of an employee on the basis of a written contract of employment for a fixed period”. 

    Further, Section 2(34)(b) ensures that fixed term employees are eligible to benefits available to permanent employees. Therefore, fixed term employees are entitled for gratuity under the SS Code.

    Practical implications:-
    -> Direct contractual hires, third party payroll employees hired on contract are eligible for gratuity under the SS code.

    -> This fundamentally shifts the the salary structure, and the underlying economics, of third party arrangements.

    -> Employers need to maintain actuarial liabilities for permanent employees and actual (or actuarial) liabilities in respect of contractual employees in the books for appropriate provisioning.

    Expanded Definition

    The definition of an employee is expanded.

    Section 2(26) explicitly lists “skilled, semi-skilled or unskilled, manual, operational, supervisory, managerial, administrative, technical, clerical or any other work”.

    Practical implications:-
    -> Hired personnel who are not classified as employees, as per the earlier definition, need to assessed whether they are classified as employees as defined in the SS code.

    Apprentice Exclusion

    Section 2(26) explicitly excludes apprentices engaged under Apprentices Act, 1961. Therefore, the SS Code does not apply to apprentices.

    As a conservative practice we prefer to include apprentices in the gratuity actuarial valuation workings and provide their liability in the books.  

    Applicability of Gratuity

    According to the First Schedule, Chapter V.
    “every shop or establishment in which ten or more employees are employed, or were employed, on any day of the preceding twelve months; and such shops or establishments as may be notified by the appropriate Government from time to time.”

    Practical implications:-
    > Employees become eligible for gratuity once the employee count crosses ten employees triggering the need to maintain actuarial provision in the books. .

    Vesting Period

    Permanent Employees

    In line with POGA 1972, section 53(1) of SS Code states that “Gratuity shall be payable to an employee on the termination of his employment after he has rendered continuous service for not less than five years at the time of retirement or resignation, death or disablement”.

    Journalists

    Section 53(1) further specifies that working journalists, defined in “clause (f) of section 2 of the Working Journalists and Other Newspaper Employees (Condition of Service) and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1955,” vesting period of 3 years is applicable.

    Practical implications:-
    -> The vesting period of five years is continued from the previous legislation for permanent employees.

    -> For Journalists, the vesting period is three years.

    Fixed Term Employees (FTEs)

    Section 53(1) of SS Code states that
    “Provided further that the completion of continuous service of five years shall not be necessary where the termination of the employment of any employee is due to death or disablement or expiration of fixed term employment or happening of any such event as may be notified by the Central Government:”

    Section 53(2) of SS Code states
    “Provided also that in the case of an employee employed on fixed term employment or a deceased employee, the employer shall pay gratuity on pro rata basis“

    With respect to FTEs, the combined effect of the above two clauses is as follows,
    – 5 year vesting period is not applicable to FTEs.
    – gratuity is payable on pro-rata basis regardless of service duration.

    It is our view that the term pro-rata basis in Section 53(2) of the Code implies gratuity shall be calculated proportionately based on the actual period of service.

    Furthermore, section 53(2) does not explicitly classify whether the deceased employee is an FTE or permanent employee. Therefore, in case of a deceased permanent employee as well, gratuity is to be paid on pro-rata basis.

    Practical implications:-
    -> FTEs vest immediately and become entitled for benefits.

    -> Under cashflow approach of Projected Unit Credit Method, pro-rata service to be considered whilst calculating death liabilities forming the overall DBO for all employees.

    Benefit formula

    Accrual rate

    In line with POGA 1972, section 53(2) of SS Code states that 
    “For every completed year of service or part thereof in excess of six months, the employer shall pay gratuity to an employee at the rate of fifteen days’ wages.”

    Further, section 53(2) – Explanation 3 states that it is clarified that in the case of a monthly rated employee, the fifteen days’ wages shall be calculated by dividing the monthly rate of wages last drawn by him by twenty-six and multiplying the quotient by fifteen.

    In line with POGA 1972 the SS Code implies that,
    – a month is to be considered as 26 days and the rate of gratuity accrual remains unchanged.
    – an employee’s service is to be rounded off to nearest 6 months whilst computing gratuity.

    Maximum Ceiling

    Section 53(3) of SS Code states that
    “(3) The amount of gratuity payable to an employee shall not exceed such amount as may be notified by the Central Government.”

    The maximum amount of gratuity payable isn’t notified by the Central Government ever since the labour codes were introduced in 2020.

    It is our view that we consider the provisions of section 164(2)(a) which state that
    “anything done or any action taken under the enactments so repealed including any rule, regulation, notification (including the notifications issued by the States), scheme, appointment, order or direction made thereunder… shall be deemed to have been done or taken or provided for such purpose under the corresponding provisions of this Code… and shall be in force to the extent they are not contrary to the provisions of this Code till they are repealed under the corresponding provisions of this Code”

    The clause states under the corresponding provisions of this Code… and shall be in force to the extent they are not contrary to the provisions of this Code till they are repealed under the corresponding provisions of this Code.

    Therefore,

    -> The gazette notification dated 29 March 2018 of updating the limit was issued under Section 4(3) of POGA 1972.
    -> We have a corresponding section 53 (3) stating the Central Government can notify the maximum ceiling, but it is not yet notified.
    -> We have a corresponding provision and SS Code does not prescribe a different ceiling or prohibit INR 20 lakhs.

    It is our view that the gazette notification dated 29 March 2018 continues in force until,
    – A new notification is issued under Section 53(3) of SS Code, OR
    – The Central Government expressly repeals the 29 March 2018 notification.

    Practical implications:
    – >The maximum ceiling notified under the gazette S.O. 1419(E). ,issued on 29th March 2018 continue to remain applicable.

    -> Though an employer can choose to pay gratuity without the upper limit. In such cases, the excess gratuity amount, over and above the maximum limit, will be taxed at applicable slab rates.

    Wages

    The definition of wages is where the SS code deviates most significantly from POGA 1972.

    POGA 1972 clearly defined gratuity salary as Basic + Dearness Allowance. Other components such as HRA, conveyance, special allowances, bonuses —were excluded. The 1972 Act also listed “any other allowance” in the listed exclusions.

    In contrast, SS Code starts the wages definition with “all remuneration” as the starting point.

    Section 2(88) states 
    “wages” means all remuneration, whether by way of salaries, allowances or otherwise, expressed in terms of money or capable of being so expressed which would, if the terms of employment, express or implied, were fulfilled, be payable to a person employed in respect of his employment or of work done in such employment, and includes,—

    The section goes on to list the inclusions and exclusions from the definition of “wages” to be considered for gratuity.

    Inclusions are :- basic salary, dearness allowance and retaining allowance.

    Exclusions are :- (statutory) bonus, value of any in-house accommodation, PF/Pension contributions, conveyance allowance (or traveling concession), special expenses pertaining to nature of employment, house rent allowance, amounts pertaining to award/settlement, overtime allowance, commission payable, gratuity/ex-gratia/retirement benefit and retrenchment compensation.

    Further, the proviso of section 2(88) implies if all the exclusions add up to more than 50% of total remuneration then we derive the excess and add back to wages.

    Excess is derived as,

    $$Excess = \left[\text{Total exclusions} – \frac{\text{Total remuneration}}{2}\right]$$

    The proviso ensures that an employee is entitled to gratuity derived on at least 50% of total remuneration.

    Our Approach

    Our view is to divide the salary into 4 buckets.

    Inclusions [A]: Basic, Dearness Allowance, Retaining Allowance.
    Exclusions [B]: Bonus, HRA, PF Contribution, Gratuity, Statutory Bonus, Commission, Conveyance & Overtime Allowances etc.
    Other Allowances [C]: Special Allowance, Supplementary Allowance, Flexi Pay etc.
    Reimbursements [D]: Sodexo Cards etc.

    Therefore, eligible wages for Gratuity are as follows,

    $$\text{Wages} = \text{Total of A} + \text{Total of C} + \text{Max [Total of B – Total Remuneration/2,0}]$$

    The max condition ensures that excess is restricted to zero and does not turn negative.

    Practical implications:-
    -> When the codes were notified in September 2020, we executed simulations for clients by increasing the basic salary to 50% and determining the impact on the gratuity liability as the codes were expected to be notified in April 2021. Needless to say, significant increases in liability were observed.

    -> Over the years, we’ve observed clients having increased basic from 20% to 40% in expectation of the notification. In these cases, the provisions have already been built up in books over the past few years. The impact of the notification will be significant for clients having basic pegged at 20-25% of comp.

    -> At the time of notification, there were challenges around determining what constitutes Total Remuneration. The Ministry of Labour issued clarifications stating that performance-linked pay can be excluded from determining the Total Remuneration.

    -> It is our view that, even if Basic is pegged at 50%, pay components which do not form part of exclusions, are considered as wages for gratuity. Therefore, depending on the salary structure, gratuity eligible salary can go up to 70% to 80% of monthly gross (excluding PF/ESIC contributions).

    Company Scheme

    In line with POGA 1972, section 53(5) CSS 2020 allows an employer to have a better gratuity scheme than the statutory minimum.

    In practice, a set of clients have removed the gratuity ceiling by amending their gratuity policy. Gratuity paid in excess of the maximum ceiling is taxed at income tax rates.

    The same practice can be continued under SS Code as well. It is evident that increase in basic + removal of ceiling can lead to exponential increases in the provision if the salary restructuring isn’t optimized.

    Compulsory Insurance

    Section 57(1) of SS Code allows state governments to invoke the compulsory insurance clause.

    Karnataka enacted the compulsory insurance rules in 2024. As of this writing, no other states have notified compulsory insurance under section 4A of POGA 1972 or section 57(1) of SS Code.

    Payment of Gratuity

    Section 56(3) SS Code ensures that an employer needs to settle gratuity within 30 days from the day it becomes payable.

    Failure to pay gratuity within the stipulated period will attract simple interest, as declared by the Central Government.

    Disputes are to be resolved via a competent Authority.

    Non-contributory nature

    The Ministry of Labour and Employment invited public comments on the first draft of Code on Social Security in 2019. This consultation was open to the public, stakeholders, trade unions, and industry bodies.

    The Code on Social Security, 2019 was referred to the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Labour on December 24, 2019. The standing committee then issued a report in July 2020 (available in the public domain).

    On page 43 of the said report, in point 13.50, the Ministry clarifies that gratuity is non-contributory in nature. Though not explicitly clarified in section 133 of SS Code, the intent of the law is to ensure the cost of gratuity is borne by the employer.

    In effect, Gratuity cannot be part of CTC.

    Accounting Impact

    Impact under Ind AS 19

    The impact on the gratuity, on account of implementation of SS Code, is classified as ‘past service cost‘. 

    Para 8 of the standard defines past service cost as
    “past service cost, which is the change in the present value of the defined benefit obligation for employee service in prior periods, resulting from a plan amendment (the introduction or withdrawal of, or changes to, a defined benefit plan)”

    The implementation of SS Code constitutes a plan amendment and the amendment results in increase in the DBO for employee service in prior periods. Due to the change in definition of wages the present value of the past service put in by employees increases. In accordance with para 57(c)(ii) of the standard, past service is recognized immediately in the profit & loss account in the period it arises.

    However, it is our view that derivation of Past Service Cost depends on how wages are derived for the gratuity valuation and thus needs to be assessed on a case-to-case basis .

    Impact under AS 15 (Revised 2005)

    In line with para 94 of the standard, if determined, the resulting past service cost is to be divided into
    > Vested past service cost (in respect of employees who’ve completed five years).
    > Non-vested past service cost (in respect of employees with less than five years of service).

    Vested past service is recognized immediately in profit and loss, in the period it arises. 

    Non-vested past service cost is taken off balance sheet (see para 55(b)) and then amortized over the average period till benefits vest. The amortization would be on a straight-line basis.

    Closing Remarks

    While the SS Code maintains the core architecture of gratuity entitlement keeping intact—the five-year vesting period, the 15-days-wages-per-year formula, and the death/disablement exceptions—the Code introduces targeted reforms that address contemporary employment realities.

    The SS Code’s most significant contribution lies in its explicit recognition and coverage of Fixed Term Employees (FTEs).

    By introducing pro-rata gratuity for FTEs, the Code acknowledges the structural transformation of India’s labour market, where third party payroll, short-term contracts, project-based engagements, and flexible employment arrangements have become prevalent.

    This reform moves beyond the industrial-era presumption of long-tenure employment and extends social security protections to workers in the platform economy, gig sector, and contract-based industries.

    The unified “wages” definition under Section 2(88) brings consistency across all social security benefits and increases the gratuity calculation base.

    We recommend employers to proactively align their systems, policies, and financial provisions with the Code’s requirements to navigate the transition seamlessly and avoid compliance risks.

    Sources

    Code on Social Security, 2020 

    Gazette Notification issued on 21st November 2025

    Standing Committee Report introduced in Lok Sabha, 2020.

    Karnataka Compulsory Gratuity Notification under section 4A of POGA, 1972.


    Disclaimer

    This article is intended for general information purposes only and should not be construed as advice or opinions on any specific facts or circumstances.

    The comments in this summary are based upon our preliminary analysis of publicly available information. The content of this document is made available on an “as is” basis, without warranty of any kind.

    Our firm disclaims any legal liability to any person or organization for loss or damage caused by or resulting from any reliance placed on the article.

  • Karnataka Compulsory Gratuity Insurance Rules, 2024

    Background

    The Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (hereinafter referred as POGA 1972) mentions the following in its clauses 1 and 4 of section 4A Compulsory Insurance,

    (1) With effect from such date as may be notified by the appropriate Government in this behalf, every employer, other than an employer or an establishment belonging to, or under the control of, the Central Government or a State Government, shall, subject to the provisions of sub-section (2), obtain an insurance in the manner prescribed, for his liability for payment towards the gratuity under this Act, from the Life Insurance Corporation of India established under the Life Insurance Corporation of India Act, 1956 (31 of 1956) or any other prescribed insurer: Provided that different dates may be appointed for different establishments or class of establishments for different areas.

    (4) The appropriate Government may, by notification, make rules to give effect to the provisions of this section and such rules may provide for the composition of the Board of Trustees of the approved gratuity fund and for the recovery by the controlling authority of the amount of the gratuity payable to an employee from the Life Insurance Corporation of India or any other insurer with whom an insurance has been taken under sub-section (1), or as the case may be, the Board of Trustees of the approved gratuity fund.

    In spirit, POGA 1972 wanted employers to fund their gratuity obligations and protect employees’ benefits. The act, however, left it for the states to decide whether they would want to make the funding compulsory.

    The essence of the sub section 1 is that an appropriate government may require an employer to go in for a compulsory gratuity insurance policy with the LIC or any other insurer. The appropriate government, as defined in the definitions, includes state governments as well. The sub section 4 allows a state government to issue a notification to that extent.

    As funding was not mandated by POGA, 1972, there are a significant number of employers who have not opted to fund their obligations and maintain un-funded provision in their books.

    After 52 years, the Karnataka state govt. chose exercise this clause in January of 2024 and mandated compulsory funding of gratuity obligations.

    Karnataka State Govt. Notification 2024

    Some of the key features of the of the notification are as follows:

    • The notification is applicable from 10th January 2024.
    • A new employer will have to obtain an insurance policy within 30 years of from the rules become applicable to it. 
    • An existing employer will have to obtain an insurance policy within 60 days from the date of commencement of the rules. 
    • An employer shall submit an application in Form-I to get the establishment registered with the Controlling Authority of the area within thirty days from the date of obtaining insurance along with the list of its employees insured.
    • An employer shall furnish the details of the employees insured, to the Controlling Authority in Form-III at the time of registration of the establishment and after that whenever there is a change in the employees insured or policies or any other pertinent information.
    • An employer will have to maintain an approved gratuity trust, which will maintain the fund.
      • Contributions to the gratuity fund shall be contributory from the employer and non-contributory for the employees.
      • The out-flow of the gratuity fund shall be only to the eligible employees at the time of their exit from service.
      • The gratuity fund is totally protected fund, and money shall not be withdrawn neither by the employer nor by the gratuity trust under any circumstances for any other purpose other than for the payment of gratuity to the eligible employees.
      • The Board of trustees of the gratuity trust at the time of exit of an employee shall duly send discharge letter and advise Insurance Company or make arrangement of payment of gratuity as per the scheme.
      • The employer shall always maintain the gratuity trust and gratuity fund, as an irrevocable system.

    Employers registered in Karnataka will have to compulsorily set up a trust fund to meet the gratuity obligations. The trust can either opt for group-gratuity scheme offered by insurers or opt for self-management of assets.

    A group gratuity scheme, offered by most life insurers, is essentially an asset management product with an insurance wrapper. It conveniences employers as the insurers takes on the burden of managing the investments in accordance with the Income Tax Act. An employer is required a contribute an annual “premium” to keep the “policy” alive. The annual premium/contribution is allowed as an expenditure/deduction, up to a certain limit, in computation of taxable income.

    Fund management charges, along with administration and policy charges, are deducted from the fund on a monthly (or quarterly) basis.

    In our experience, most employers opt-in for group gratuity scheme offered by insurers and avoid the hassle of managing the monies on their own.