Apriori Advisors LLP

Employee Benefits | Non-Life Insurance

Category: Case-Studies

  •  Mr. Pillai v HDFC Bank

    Mr. P.V. Unnikrishna Pillai is an ex-employee of HDFC Bank.

    According to market practice, at the end of his service, he was paid 5.95 lacs as gratuity for 16 years of service based on his last drawn basic + DA. Mr. Pillai observed a component named personal pay in his salary breakup and wanted to verify whether component could be a part of the salary eligible for gratuity.

    According to POGA 1972, wages are defined as

    “Wages” means all emoluments which are earned by an employee while on duty or on leave in accordance with the terms and conditions of his employment and which are paid or are payable to him in cash and includes dearness allowance but does not include any bonus, commission, house rent allowance, overtime wages and any other allowance.”

    The above is interpreted as follows to arrive the salary for Gratuity,

    • include basic pay & DA
    • exclude allowances and other components (as defined in the Act).

    Mr. Pillai found that personal pay does not form a part of the “exclusions” list. Whatever is not (explicitly) excluded can be a part of the inclusions (i.e. basic + DA).

    Therefore, if personal pay were to be included in the definition of Wages, his gratuity eligibility would be 13.17 lacs (v/s 5.95 lacs actually paid).

    Mr. Pillai went to the Controlling Authority claiming that his gratuity was underestimated and personal pay should be a part of his gratuity workings. Turns out, the ruling turned out to be in his favor. Mr.Aneish Ravindra, Assistant Labour Commissioner, Ernakulam, mentioned in his order.

    “In the instant case, it is pertinent to note that with respect to the components of the salary of the applicant, the term used by the employer is ‘personal pay’ instead of ‘personal allowance’ and all other components of the salary are specifically termed as ‘allowances’.”

    The order specifically mentions that if it was personal allowance, it would be excluded. Since, it’s not the case, Mr. Pillai’s claim stands.

    HDFC appealed.

    The Deputy Chief Labour Commissioner (Central) ruled in HDFC’s favor saying that gratuity is to be paid only on basic pay, personal pay is not be included in the definition of wages. However, at the time of final hearing, Mr. Pillai’s counsel was not present due to serious illness and Mr. Pillai was not able to properly defend his case.

    The Appellate Authority ruled in HDFC’s favor.

    Mr. Pillai persisted and went to High Court to appeal the ruling and argued that the order was ex-parte (decision was made without hearing the other party’s side). The High Court ruled in Mr. Pillai’s favor and ordered The Appellate Authority to conduct the appeal hearing again.

    The ruling was passed in October 2024. As of this writing (March 2025), there are no further updates on the case.

    In the interim, HDFC faces some serious financial implications due to the preliminary order.

    • Should it include personal pay to determine gratuity for employees resigning henceforth?
    • Should it include the component in determining the year-end actuarial liability? The following is a snapshot from HDFC’s Mar’22 balance sheet.
    • As on Mar’22, the Gratuity liability was 375 cr. If personal pay were included in working out Gratuity, assuming Mr. Pillai’s increase of 120% across the board, this could go up to 840 Cr.
    • If the company doesn’t choose to fund the liability, the net balance sheet provision can up from 86 Cr. to 565 Cr. An approx. ~6x increase in a single financial year.

    The interim order is bound impact everyone else and not just HDFC. It calls for employers to review their pay components. With Code on Social Security implementation around the corner, the outcome of this case has the potential to set a jurisdictional precedent for the industry at large.


  • Contractual Workers’ Gratuity | IIT Bombay

    Contractual Workers’ Gratuity | IIT Bombay

    A case has occurred in IIT-Bombay in respect of gratuity eligibility of contractual workers.

    The following is a detailed breakdown of the ongoing case, its potential financial burden and other considerations. The outcome of this case has the potential to cause significant financial repercussions with employers having contractual employees. 

    Background

    IIT Bombay (IIT-B) employs close to 1800 contractual workers in capacities such as cleaning, gardening, construction work etc. required on campus.

    Raman Garase, one such contractual worker, worked for 39 years as a gardener and attained retirement in December 2019.  Garase was expecting to be allowed to work beyond the retirement age as he was of good health,  and as IIT-B had made exceptions for contractual workers working beyond their age of retirement. 

    Upon retirement, Garase claimed gratuity of INR 4,28,805 from IIT-B and was denied on the grounds that as per the prevailing Acts, he was not entitled to Gratuity.

    Garase, along with two colleagues (Dadarao Ingale and Tanaji Lad) decided to move to the labour commission in 2020. In January 2022, the Central Assistant Labour Commissioner, who is also the controlling authority under the Payment of Gratuity Act, stated that Garase was entitled to receive INR 4.28 lakh from the institute. Further, his colleagues Lad and Ingale, were also entitled to gratuity as per the order. 

    IIT-B decided to contest the order. The Chief Deputy Labour Commissioner, who is the appellate authority in the matter, also issued an order in favor of Garase, Lad and Ingale in  April 2024, which IIT-B decided to contest in court.

    Eventually, Garase lost hope of receiving the gratuity monies and ended his life on 2nd May 2024.

    Expected Costs

    If IIT – B had decided to pay Garase, Lad and Ingale, it would have to pay the rest of the contractual workers as well. This would constitute a significant amount, especially, given that contractual worker’s gratuity has not been accounted for, since their hiring.

    On average, if we conservatively assume a basic pay of INR 15,000 and 30 years of service at the time of retirement for 1800 workers, then IIT-B would end up paying close to INR 46.7 crores only in respect of Gratuity.

    Realistically, IIT-B would be looking at an estimated cash outflow of 45 – 60 crores during retirement of these contractual workers. Say, IIT-B decides to provide for their liability in the books, it would not get the benefit of long term discounting as most workers are already nearing retirement. So the provision would be a significant hit to the books.

    Gratuity Eligibility

    The Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (POGA  1972) carries no explicit provisions with respect to contractual workers.

    It defines an employee as, “employee” means any person (other than an apprentice) who is employed for wages, whether the terms of such employment are expressed or implied, in any kind of work, manual or otherwise, in or in connection with the work of a factory, mine, oilfield, plantation, port, railway company, shop or other establishment to which this Act applies.”

    By this definition, contractual workers are employees of the payroll vendor and are entitled to benefits. In our experience, this is reflected in the current market practice. We have observed that, for contractual workers, provident fund is deducted from their pay, are entitled to time off, despite being on a yearly contract. 

    Thus gratuity and other benefits if any, are outlined in the contract signed with them, the benefits are due upon retirement, resignation or untimely death. The nature and the quantum of the benefits promised in the contract by the vendor would depend upon the agreement between the employer and the vendor. In any case, the vendor would have the bare minimum benefits as prescribed by the law.

    For instance, let us assume the benefits are not promised as per the contract. A typical market practice we have observed is, if a contractual worker becomes eligible for gratuity, the employer pays the gratuity to the vendor and the vendor settles it on a case-to-case basis. However, such a settlement would be at the imperative of the employer.

    Accounting of Contractual Workers’ Gratuity

    In the case of IIT-B, it is evident that liability, with respect to contractual workers, was not provided in the books as the contractual workers would not fall under the definition of the “employee” as defined in POGA, 1972.

    However, para 6 of the Accounting Standard (Revised 2005) is worth considering.

    “An employee may provide services to an enterprise on a full-time, part-time, permanent, casual or temporary basis. For the purpose of this Standard, employees include whole-time directors and other management personnel.”

    Therefore, from an accounting perspective, gratuity liability with respect to temporary employees are to be provided for in the books. In this situation, the vendor would have to provide for contractual workers’ liability in its books and consequently IIT-B would have to provide for their liability in the books.

    Indian Accounting Standard 19 (Ind AS19), an upgraded version of Accounting Standard (Revised 2005), reflects the same in its para 7. 

    Concluding Remarks

    IIT-B has moved to court despite two orders made in favor of the contractual workers. The outcome of the case remains to be seen.

    In the interim, a duration-wise analysis of the retirement of contractual workers and their gratuity amounts due at retirement, would help IIT-B to get a year-wise overview of expenses expected to occur in the future. If IIT-B chooses to set some monies aside, it might just hedge the risk partially in case the court favors the contractual workers.

    Going simply by the provisions of the accounting standard, IIT-B needs to maintain the necessary provisions in the books in respect of the contractual workers. 

    Sources

    https://thewire.in/labour/gratuity-stalled-despite-2-favourable-orders-ex-iit-bombay-contract-worker-dies-by-suicide

    https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/mumbai/former-iit-b-contract-worker-dies-by-suicide-in-powai-9304427

    https://article-14.com/post/an-iit-bombay-gardener-s-suicide-reveals-the-spread-of-labour-practices-designed-to-deny-indian-workers-their-rights–664c066f73898

    https://www.hindustantimes.com/cities/mumbai-news/retired-iit-b-employee-dies-by-suicide-101714677429705.html